What questions should I ask when interviewing a babysitter?

The 12 most useful babysitter interview questions cover three areas: (1) Experience and approach — how many children have they cared for, what ages, how they handle tantrums or refusals; (2) Logistics and availability — weekly schedule, cancellation policy, how far in advance they need notice; (3) Emergencies — CPR certification status, what they'd do if a child got hurt, whether they know your nearest hospital. The goal isn't a checklist — it's hearing how they think about childcare, not just what credentials they have.

What are red flags in a babysitter interview?

Key red flags: vague or evasive answers about how they'd handle an emergency ("I'd figure it out"); inability to name a specific difficult situation they've navigated; no CPR certification and no interest in getting one; asking you to skip the trial session; references who sound scripted or who decline to speak candidly. Green flags: specific stories about challenging situations, proactive questions about your children's routines, references who volunteer details without prompting.

Should I do a trial session with a new babysitter?

Yes — always do a paid trial session before leaving a new sitter alone with your children. A 1–2 hour trial where you're present but not hovering lets you see how the sitter interacts with your kids without the pressure of you being gone. Pay the full hourly rate for this session. A sitter who objects to a trial is a red flag; a good sitter understands it's standard practice and often welcomes the chance to meet the children in a low-stakes environment.

What information should I give a babysitter before they start?

Before a babysitter's first session, share: your children's names, ages, and key personalities; daily routine and bedtime process; any allergies or medical conditions; emergency contacts (both parents + a local backup adult + pediatrician's number); house rules and where things are; your agreed rate and how you'll pay. The interview is a two-way process — the best candidates will also ask you questions, and the quality of their questions tells you a lot.

Parenting April 8, 2026 · 6 min read

Babysitter Interview Questions: 12 That Actually Tell You What You Need to Know

Most babysitter interview question lists are 40 items long and feel like an HR audit. Here are 12 questions — and what to actually listen for in the answers — that reveal whether someone will be a good fit for your family.

The goal of a babysitter interview isn't just to screen out bad candidates. It's to set expectations with someone you're hoping to build a long-term relationship with. The best sitters aren't hired once and replaced — they become part of how your family runs.

That changes how you ask questions. You're not interrogating. You're having a real conversation to see if this works for both of you.

Questions About Experience and Approach

These five questions reveal how someone thinks about working with children — not just whether they've done it before.

Question 01

"How long have you been babysitting, and what ages have you worked with most?"

Listen for: Specificity. "A few years" tells you less than "Since I was 16 — mostly 2-5 year olds, but I've done a few newborn sits for my neighbor." Someone who remembers their experiences in detail has actually been present for them. Also note whether the ages they mention align with your kids.

Question 02

"What do you usually do with kids when you sit? Walk me through a typical evening."

Listen for: Engagement. Do they describe a routine that involves actually being with the kids — activities, dinner, bath, books — or is it "I make sure they eat, then we watch TV"? Neither is automatically disqualifying, but you want the answer to match your expectations for how evenings in your house run.

Question 03

"Tell me about a time a kid was upset or had a hard moment. What did you do?"

Listen for: Calmness and specificity. A good answer includes a real situation and a clear response — not just "I stayed calm and comforted them." Someone who's actually been through it will have a story. Someone who hasn't will give a generic answer that sounds practiced.

Question 04

"How do you handle it when a child doesn't want to follow the rules — bedtime, screen limits, that kind of thing?"

Listen for: Respect for your rules combined with warmth. The right answer isn't "I'm strict" or "I let them do what they want." It's some version of: "I try to follow whatever the parents have told me, and if a kid pushes back I stay consistent but don't make it a battle." That's the practical reality.

Question 05

"Are you CPR certified? When does it expire?"

Listen for: A clear yes or no — and the date. Many parents require current CPR certification, especially for younger children. If they're not certified but seem otherwise like a strong fit, you can make it a condition of hiring. What you don't want: someone who is vague or defensive about it. It's a simple, professional question and a simple professional answer. Once hired, record their certification status in your sitter contact profile so you don't have to remember it.

Questions About Logistics and Availability

These reveal reliability before you rely on them.

Question 06

"What does your availability look like typically — weekends, weeknights, both?"

Listen for: Clarity and honesty. "Pretty flexible" can mean genuinely available or it can mean they're not sure yet. Push a little: "If we wanted a standing Friday night, is that something you could commit to?" A reliable sitter knows their schedule. An unreliable one doesn't.

Question 07

"What's your policy if something comes up and you need to cancel?"

Listen for: Ownership. "I try not to cancel" isn't a policy. A good answer sounds like: "I give as much notice as possible — at least 24 hours unless it's an emergency — and I try to help find a replacement if I can." That's how a professional thinks. If they haven't thought about this, it's worth discussing your expectations explicitly before you book them. You might also share your household's cancellation approach at this point in the conversation.

Question 08

"Do you drive? Do you have your own car?"

Listen for: A straightforward answer plus any questions they have about your expectations. If you need a sitter who can do school pickups or take kids to activities, this is essential. If you don't, it still affects logistics for late nights or last-minute sits. Some of the best sitters don't drive — just know what you need before you count on something that isn't there.

Questions About Emergencies

These are the most important questions most parents forget to ask.

Question 09

"If one of the kids had an allergic reaction or got hurt badly — what would you do?"

Listen for: Instinct to call 911 first, then parents. Any answer that starts with "I'd call you" rather than "I'd call 911 if it looked serious" is a yellow flag. A babysitter should know that in a real emergency, you call emergency services immediately — not spend time reaching parents who might be forty minutes away. This conversation is also the right moment to go over your emergency contacts, any allergy medications, and where you keep the first aid kit.

Question 10

"Have you ever had to deal with a real emergency — anything that felt serious — while sitting?"

Listen for: Honesty, not a résumé answer. "No" is completely fine. "Yes, [child] had a bad fall and I had to stay calm while calling the parents" tells you a lot. What you don't want is someone who sounds like they've never thought about this possibility at all. Kids have accidents. The interview is where you establish that this person will handle it.

What You Should Tell Them

The interview is two-directional. By the end, your candidate should know:

What to cover before you finish

Your schedule and frequency. "We need someone most Friday nights, occasionally Saturdays." Be honest about how consistent the gig is — a good sitter will turn down steady income elsewhere if they're counting on yours.
Your kids' personalities and any special considerations. Allergies, sleep issues, separation anxiety, anything that changes how the evening goes. Don't wait until the first sit to share this.
Your rate expectation. Or ask theirs. Either way, have the number conversation in the interview, not the night you hand them cash. Knowing the going rate for your area helps anchor this conversation.
How and when you pay. "We do Venmo, usually that night" or "We pay cash at the end of each sit." Clear expectations prevent awkwardness later.
Your communication style. "Feel free to text if anything comes up" vs. "We'll leave our number but prefer not to be interrupted unless it's important." Let them know what you expect.

Green Flags and Red Flags

Green flags

Asks about your kids before you finish the intro
Specific answers to experience questions — real stories, not scripts
Clear, honest availability with caveats they volunteer
Has thought about emergencies; knows to call 911 first
Comfortable discussing rates directly
References who will actually pick up the phone
Asks what your kids like to do

Red flags

Vague on all experience ("yeah, I've babysat a lot")
No answer for what they do when kids push back
Defensive or dismissive about CPR or emergencies
Availability changes significantly after one follow-up question
Can't name a specific child they've cared for
Uncomfortable with any part of the payment conversation
Doesn't ask a single question about your family

One final note: trust your instincts. The interview is data, but it isn't everything. How someone shows up for a trial session — whether the kids respond to them, how they handle the first five minutes of uncertainty — tells you more than any question you'll ever ask.

Hired someone good? Keep everything about them in one place.

SitterLark stores your sitters' rates, availability, CPR status, and notes — and shares everything with both parents instantly. No more hunting for the details before every booking.

Download SitterLark Free iOS · Free for up to 2 sitters · No credit card required